Thursday 19 October 2017

Why Facebook should be taxed and how to do it

The new information technologies have created a whole range of companies that have become extremely profitable. The most successful ones are in the list of the top ten most valuable companies in the world. Valuable here means the monetary value of all outstanding shares of these companies; their capitalization as economists call it.
Alphabet (better known as Google), Amazon, Microsoft, Facebook, Alibaba, are each worth $ 400 billion or more in the stock markets. They produce hardly anything tangible. They "make" information. These information companies are extremely successful. They also give rise to new problems.
The most salient characteristics of information companies is that the marginal cost of the information they produce is zero. To make a YouTube movie you have some fixed costs, such as a camera, a laptop and an Internet connection. But once the video has been made, you can broadcast it without increasing costs. Whether there are 10, 100 or 100,000 viewers of the movie does not change the costs of the movie producer anymore. The marginal cost (the cost of one additional unit viewed by someone) is zero.
That’s not all. The more viewers the moviemaker reaches, the more valuable his YouTube movie becomes. If he/she reaches an audience of, say, 1 million viewers, advertisers will be interested and will be willing to pay the creator of the video for placing ads. The more viewers there are, the more the advertiser is willing to pay. The YouTube producer thus produces something that has a marginal cost equal to zero and a marginal revenue that increases with the number of viewers. The more people reached with the movie, the richer the moviemaker gets without having to do something special.
Such a business model creates a number of problems. The first one is that information companies create a lot of economic value without the use of many production factors. You hardly need employees to generate a lot of income. Facebook with a capitalization of $ 400 billion employs 21,000 people. Walmart, which has a capitalization of 220 billion, has 2.1 million employees. Thus Facebook that is almost twice as large in terms of capitalization than Walmart counts only one percent of the number of employees of the latter. This means that a very high level of economic value is distributed to very few people. An inequality time bomb.
A second problem has to do with the fact that the people who join such an information platform (for example Facebook) actually give away information about themselves for free. This information becomes more valuable as more people join the platform. The big data on private information makes it possible to place highly targeted ads. The dream of all advertisers.
So companies like Facebook produce information that generates a lot of revenue using as ”raw material” the private information that they acquire for free from their users. They are great money machines generating huge wealth that hardly has to be shared and can be kept by the happy few in these companies.
Such a situation is untenable. More and more economic value is distributed to less and less people. What can be done about this? Here is my proposal. Facebook realized $ 26 billion in advertising revenue in 2016. This revenue was actually made possible thanks to the free "raw material" of the information provided by Facebook users. The government could apply a tax of 50%, for example, assuming that at least half of that income is due to the free information. That means 13 billion dollars. There are now about 1.23 billion Facebook users. So that means (rounded) $ 10 per user and per year. That seems to me to be a good estimate of the yearly value of the information provided by the individual user to Facebook.
So my proposal becomes: a 10-dollar tax per user to be paid by Facebook. Zuckerberg will be a little less rich after this tax, but will still have a lot of money left.
There are many issues with such a proposal. It should preferably (but not necessarily) be coordinated internationally. Not an easy thing. There is also the issue of what the government should do with the revenue. One possibility would be to return 10 dollars to the Facebook users every year. Alternatively, the government could use the revenue to invest in education, the environment or sustainable energy.

I think these are separate issues that can be resolved and that do not stand in the way to tax Facebook and other information companies (e.g. Google, Amazon) that use private information freely and transform this into a fabulous money machine that benefits only a few. 

41 comments:

  1. Quite informative post. I really liked reading all this. Anyways, being an entrepreneur I know how important it is to use FB for connecting to potential customers. When we started out we had hard time to get customers but since we hired the expert facebook ads campaign management team we have been getting amazing revenue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is really a helpful blog to find some different source to add my knowledge. I came into aware of new professional blog and I am impressed with suggestions of author. Wedding videography DC

    ReplyDelete
  3. تتميز شركة دراسة لتقديم خدمات البحث العلمي الحصول علي خدمة التحليل الاحصائيالتي يحتاج الكثير من الباحثين اليها حتي يحصلوا علي نتائج دقيقة علي عينة البحث

    ReplyDelete
  4. يتواجد لدي شبكة المعلومات العربية الكثير من التقنيات الحديثة التي تقضي تماما علي المشكلات التي يتعرض اليها الباحث في تنفيذ الاطار النظري التي يجمع المادة العلمية التي يجمعها الباحث

    ReplyDelete
  5. يحتاج الكثير من الباحثين الحصول من خلال موقع مكتبتك علي العديد من الانواع المختلفة للتقنيات العالية في الجودة منها خدمة توفير دراسات اجنبية مترجمة يستكمل بها الباحث بحثه

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for sharing a good mythological post related a biblical plumb line for national leadership. download instagram stories

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am searching for many days like this type of blog, today will got it this, am really satisfied with your blog, it’s really helped me a lot, thank you so much for share this wonderful blog, thanks to read my I hope I see your blog soon keep working, if any one searching best website designing company in Delhi please click my website and visit this we are able for you any time and we are made best website for you in cheap rate if are really grow your business so come with me on my website.
    Best Website Designing Company in delhi

    ReplyDelete
  8. Am visit of many blog but not get valuable information, but after seen your blog provide it me a lot of valuable and useful information I really like to thank you so much for share this information with us, if are inserted in grow up your life style and also grow up your looking so please come on my website am put it on many information so and visit again time thank you so much for read my comment I hope your also like my comment and you also go on my web page.
    Lifestyle Magazine

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for the another great article. I have gone through your post. Nicely written on selected topic. keep sharing your best post in the future as well. it will give more info to us and thank for this wonderful post.
    Website Designing Company In India | Best SEO Services In India

    ReplyDelete
  10. شركة MK
    للتسويق الالكتروني
    افضل شركة تسويق الكتروني
    01015375663

    صيانة كريازى خدمة العملاء
    خدمة عملاء كريازى الخط الساخن

    هنا تجدوا جميع الامكانيات المتاحة لعمل الصيانة المنزلية الشاملة و بدرجة امتياز صيانه كريازي بقطع غيار اصلية و بأذون مخزن معتمدة من التوكيل المعتمد لصيانة كريازي في دولة جمهورية مصر العربية .
    يقوم بإجراء الصيانة فريق عمل من مهندسين و فنيين مدربين من مركز صيانة كريازي باسطول من السيارات لخدمة صيانة كريازي المنتشرة في جميع محافظات دولة جمهورية مصر العربية او بالمركز الرئيسي لصيانة كريازي بالعاصمة المصرية القاهرة .



    صيانة وايت ويل
    صيانة زانوسي
    صيانة سامسونج
    صيانة يونيفرسال
    صيانة كريازي
    صيانة اريستون
    صيانة وايت بوينت
    ا صيانة ال جي

    ReplyDelete
  11. FURNISHYA, a Home Furnishing brand, Furnishya have many traditional designs on bed, bath and kitchen. Our products are not only elegant, eclectic and eccentric, but are also thoughtfully crafted to make your experience of living a comfortable lifestyle, more comfortable.
    With thoughtful living at heart, we create products to give you an experience. And how do we do it? We do it with love, care and innovation to make, better.
    Home Kitchen

    ReplyDelete
  12. i advise anyone looking for a forex and crypto trader in terms of account mentorshp to reach out to Mrs Thomas Mary for she has really help me know the better part of trade. I have made a lot of profit with her guidiance. you can reach her on her email adress thomasmary4554@gmail.com or reach her on her whatsapp +447508347797.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great tips! Thanks for sharing useful information... https://hairsalonmanhattanbeach.com

    ReplyDelete
  14. Excellent write-up. I absolutely appreciate this website. Keep writing!

    Feel free to surf to my homepage ... 카지노사이트

    ReplyDelete
  15. UBIQCOM is the best FTTH Solution Provider in India. FTTH is one of the latest technologies that UBIQCOM use to provide high speed broadband service to their internet users. With FTTH solutions, the “in-house” connectivity may be based on fiber, coaxial cable, copper or wireless technologies.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot
    스포츠토토

    ReplyDelete
  17. You ought to be a part of a contest for one of the best websites on the net.
    I will recommend this website!
    성인웹툰

    ReplyDelete
  18. I truly appreciate this post. I’ve been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. 스포츠토토

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great post, beautiful weblog with great informational content. This is a really interesting and informative content. 릴게임

    ReplyDelete
  20. This website has very good content. Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I will be sure to bookmark your blog. 스포츠토토

    ReplyDelete
  21. I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site. Feel free to visit my website;
    Sports Toto Zone is Toto , Sports Toto , Proto , Private Toto, Powerball , Safety Playground , Eat Validation ,Topics , Toto Web , Major Sites | 토토 | Toto site ranking.

    ReplyDelete
  22. i am appreciative of your assisced you visited my web site for that reason i came to “go back the favor”. I'm searching for matters to beautify my net website! I assume its good enough to apply a number of your ideas! This is the exceptional mind-set, nonetheless is simply no longer help to make each sence by any means preaching approximately that mather. Virtually any approach many thank you in addition to i had undertaking to promote your very own article in to delicius though it's miles seemingly a quandary using your records web sites can you please recheck the idea. Thanks another time. 토토핫

    ReplyDelete
  23. each one of the substance you said in pules and using the informative recommendations. Looking ahead to read such informed articles. Pleasant facts, treasured and fantastic design, as proportion precise stuff with good ideas and ideas, plenty of terrific records and inspiration, both of which i need, thanks to offer this sort of useful statistics here . I’m going to read this. I’ll be sure to come again. Thank you for sharing. And additionally this article offers the mild wherein we will observe the fact. That is very fine one and offers indepth statistics. Thank you for this fine article. I used to be surfing the internet for facts and got here throughout your blog. I am inspired by using the records you have got on this weblog. It shows how nicely you apprehend this difficulty. 파워볼전용사이트

    ReplyDelete
  24. thank you! I research some thing new and tough from here. It'll constantly be exciting to read content from different authors and exercise a little some thing from different websites. I would like to suggest you go to our article it presents you information. It can enjoy any age of peoples. Fortnite has various skins and avatars to make gaming intresting. Examine my weblog and get these skins totally free. Experience this blog. This is my first time i go to right here. I found such a lot of unique stuff in your weblog, particularly its dialogue. From the heaps of comments on your articles, i guess i'm now not the most effective one having all of the amusement here! Keep up the coolest paintings. I have been which means to jot down some thing like this on my website and you have given me an concept. 카지노사이트

    ReplyDelete
  25. i am typically to running a blog i in reality appreciate your content material. Your content has absolutely peaks my hobby. I will bookmark your site and keep checking for brand new data. Cool publish. There’s an issue together with your site in chrome, and you can want to check this… the browser is the marketplace leader and a very good element of human beings will pass over your first-rate writing because of this hassle. That is very educational content and written properly for a alternate. It is exceptional to peer that some humans still recognize how to write a exceptional publish.! Whats up there, you have completed an great process. I’ll virtually digg it and for my part endorse to my buddies. I’m assured they’ll be benefited from this website. This could be superb plus meanful. This will be thrilling website online. Leading is alternatively handy element. You may have severely made it less difficult for lots folks that seem to test web page and provide those parents usefull data and records. 먹튀보증

    ReplyDelete
  26. best facts, valuable and fantastic layout, as share suitable stuff with top thoughts and ideas, masses of fantastic information and proposal, each of which i want, thanks to offer this type of beneficial facts right here. I was simply browsing via the net looking for a few facts and came across your weblog. I'm inspired by the statistics that you have on this blog. It suggests how nicely you recognize this situation. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for greater. Genuinely first-class and exciting post. I used to be looking for this kind of information and enjoyed studying this one. Hold posting. Thank you for sharing. 안전놀이터

    ReplyDelete
  27. Our furniture range is the perfect combination of quality and excellence. We as the top 10 Best furniture Manufacturers in India, provide the world-class product range keeping in mind the diverse needs of the customers all around the globe. Our website is ...
    Modular Workstation Manufacturer in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  28. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete